Seth's PhD Blog

Just another WordPress.com weblog

Archive for the ‘phd’ Category

Requirements for a Dissertation (MindMap)

Posted by phdblogmeister on December 15, 2007

dissertation-mindmap.jpeg

Structure of the Proposal – Chapter 1• Introduction “Since the late 1990s, scholars and practitioners investigating the global economy havestruggled in understanding if whether or not a developing country’s “e-readiness” is or canbe an emerging factor in accelerating economic growth and political stability…”• Background to the Study Why is this an issue What has been accomplished to date• Statement of the Problem What are the gaps in the body of knowledge• Purpose of the Study An attempt (based on empirical research) to close a gap or explain why there is a gap• Research Questions and/or Hypotheses A question: “Is e-readiness a significant factor in accelerating economic growth andpolitical stability?” Related hypotheses: Null hypothesis – “There is no relationship between e-readiness andeconomic growth and/or political stability in a developing country.” Alternate hypothesis – “There is a relationship between e-readiness and economic growthand/or political stability in a developing country• Nature of the Study Quantitative, qualitative or both• Significance of the Study May close a gap in the body of knowledge May help developing countries close the gaps in the distribution of wealth andresources in the global economy• Definition of Terms E-Readiness Global economy Developing country Economic growth Political stability• Assumptions and Limitations Identify the assumptions that “allow” you to conduct the research Identify the limitations to your proposed research, particularly as theypertain to your choice of research design/methodology

Structure of the Proposal – Chapter 2• The literature search should provide knowledge and citations to support threethings: Rationale for undertaking the research Background of previous research bearing on the topic (helpful hint – youshould follow the related literature back to its seminal origins) Theory generating research questions and/or hypotheses• Every successful literature review addresses basic issues The review helps to focus the topic within the scope of the related literature The review substantiates the researcher’s hypothesis, or research question, withtheories of respected authorities in the field The review shows how the topic will contribute to the research field• The purpose of the literature review is to offertheoretical and/or research support for the problemyou want to investigate and for the methodology youplan to use in your research• The expectation is that you will be able to prepareChapter 1 and Chapter 3 once you have completed thereview of the literature on your topic

Structure of the Proposal – Chapter 3• The research design should derive logically from the problemstatement• The discussion of method should include sources of data(sampling), instrumentation, the collection of data, the analysisof data, and participants• The design should provide for field and/or pilot testing ifappropriate• The details of each step taken to respond to the researchquestion(s) or test the hypotheses should be clearly described• The following elements, where relevant, should be identified: Who or what is being studied? How will it (they) be studied? How will the information be gathered? How will the analysis be undertaken?• The ethical considerations of your proposed research should beaddressed Do you speak fluent “IRB” yet? Are you planning to collect data from within your employerorganization?

Structure of the Dissertation – Chapter 4• Chapter 4 presents findings and analysis• Brief summary of the research design and methods employed inyour study• Presentation of the first research question and/or hypothesis andthe quantitative or qualitative analyses employed to test/addressthat question/hypothesis Typically, quantitative findings are summarized in tables, graphs,and/or figures followed by brief interpretations of the statisticaltests used to test the hypothesis Note that any extensive output should be placed in an appendix• Repeat the process for the second research question/hypothesis,and repeat the process until the findings in support of allresearch questions/hypotheses are presented• Each research question/hypothesis should represent asubheading in this chapter• Each of your statistical tests and organizing your findings intables, graphs, or figures should be reviewed with your Mentor• With qualitative studies state each research questions and reportthe results by an analysis of the data• Content analyses are usually presented case by case with anattempt to refine or modify the research question or hypothesesin the presentation of each case• Regardless of the qualitative or quantitative nature of yourfindings and analytic procedures used to interpret your data, it isnot the purpose of Chapter 4 to engage in elaborate discussionsof your findings

Structure of Dissertation – Chapter 5• Summary and discussion of results, conclusions, and recommendations An overview and discussion of the entire study including beginning with a restatement of thepurpose statement The types of literature reviewed and their relevance The methodology used The study’s findings• Analysis and interpretation of what was found in the study and recommendations foradditional research This section typically goes beyond the study’s findings in an attempt to place them within theconceptual framework• The only place in the dissertation where you may have your own opinion General recommendations – those developed directly from the data Recommendations for further research – including ideas for further study that have arisen butare not supported by the data – here you can elaborate on what you thought your woulddiscover and why you did or didn’t… your suggestions for further research are based on yournewly “informed” opinions

Structure of the Dissertation – References and Appendix • References (Bibliography) No texts (except to support Chapter 3) Peer reviewed journal articles Previous dissertations A small number of monographs/books and “popular” literature • Appendix (Proposal) Copies of data gathering instruments, permission letters, informed consent, i.e., anydocumentation that pertains to inviting participants, getting their consent, collecting data IRB application including the CITI completion certificate • Appendix (Dissertation) Everything except the IRB application Do not “pad” the Appendix to add “heft” to your completed dissertation… rule of thumb:unless you make reference to information in your Appendix in the body of the dissertation,then it shouldn’t be there… another rule of thumb: and if you reference your Appendix then why isn’t that information in the body of your dissertation?

Posted in dissertation | Tagged: , , | Leave a Comment »

Requirements for a Prospectus (MindMap)

Posted by phdblogmeister on December 15, 2007

prospectus-mindmap.jpeg

Seth

Posted in prospectus | Tagged: , | Leave a Comment »

residency

Posted by phdblogmeister on December 15, 2007

Many people have asked me what a PhD residency is like in my field (IT) and school (Capella). First, Capella University doctoral learners are required to complete three in-person residencies otherwise know as Colloquia in addition to their courses.

Residencies allows one to interact with fellow learners and faculty in person, as well as gather important information to help you through your program. Each Colloquia lasts for 1 full week and is presented in a structured, lecture-style format covering areas such as:

  • Developing the Scholar-Practitioner
  • Critical Analysis Skills
  • Research Skills
  • Professional Communication Skills
  • Development of Learning Communities
  • Program Specific Content

Each learner can select the tracks they are most interested in and their is no grading involved. It is advised  you bring copies of a summary of yourself to share with faculty: your contact information, your profession, which program/specialization you are in, the courses you have taken, the dissertation topic and research methodology you are interested in using, and other relevant information about yourself that you wish to share with a potential faculty tutor, committee member, and/or mentor.

Seth

Posted in phd | Tagged: , , , | Leave a Comment »

phd folders

Posted by phdblogmeister on December 13, 2007

I started keeping a folder for those that I ran across and found it interesting for a variety of reasons. I renamed the files for easy reference and have the following rather small database:

  • 80 pg Servant-Leader Dissertation (Walden)
  • 149 pg Enterprise Database Management Dissertation (Miami)
  • 161 pg Project Management Dissertation (Walden)
  • 191 pg Generation X Dissertation (UOP)
  • 217 pg Intercultural Leadership Dissertation (UOP)
  • 435 pg Integrated Project Planning and Control Dissertation (Colorado)

In the names I attempt to capture some important metadata including the length, the topic and the school.

It is important to note that length is not a factor in success as some of the better papers are the shorter ones.

Other folders I keep organized for the PhD include:

  • Capella Advisor
  • Capella Mentors and Staff Bios
  • Chicago – PhD Presentations and Handouts
  • Comp Exams (and related)
  • Dissertation Collection (and related)
  • Future Paper Ideas
  • Library & Research
  • Motivation
  • Registration, Class Lists and Finance
  • Theories (Cross-Study)
  • Tools and Books (to buy, sell, etc)
  • Visualization
  • Writing

Under the folder Theories (Cross-Study), for example I have:

  • Hypothesis Testing
  • Maslow’s hierarchy of needs
  • Mixed Method
  • Org. Theory
  • Positivism
  • Qualitative (Research Types, etc)
  • Research Design and Cases (From Cooper & Schindler)
  • Sampling

While this is just a start, I hope this encourages others to organize their academic life. On student I meet at my last colloquia gathered over 150 citations in preparation for his Comps, which of course he passed just the other day.

Seth

Posted in phd | Tagged: , | Leave a Comment »

my thesis ideas… 12-8-2007

Posted by phdblogmeister on December 9, 2007

For my dissertation I am looking less at doing detailed data crunching, but more on how participants (project managers, geeks, managers, etc) react (or interact) with complex data and/or “information overload” for the very purpose of improving their own (or the organizations) information management.

Seth

Posted in research, thesis ideas | Tagged: , , , | Leave a Comment »

Websites to check out on visualization

Posted by phdblogmeister on December 7, 2007

  • information aesthetics
  • visualcomplexity.com
  • data mining (and more)
  • flowing data
  • eagereyes.org
  • many eyes
  • Junk Charts
  • Stat. Graphics & Data Visualization
  • Pictures of Numbers
  • Forest and the Trees
  • visual-literacy.org
  • programmableweb
  • knowledge-visualization.org
  • serial consign
  • coding horror
  • bokardo – social design
  • Posted in info vis, thesis ideas | Tagged: | Leave a Comment »

    Information Visualization Journal

    Posted by phdblogmeister on November 30, 2007

    http://www.palgrave-journals.com/ivs/index.html

    Forthcoming in 2007 is our special issue on Visual Analytics by Guest Editor: Pak Chung Wong. Free online access to these papers will be available to you upon publication.

    Included in the Visual Analytics special issue:

    • Interactive Wormhole Detection and Evaluation;
      Weichao Wang, Aidong Lu
    • NetLens: Iterative Exploration of Content-Actor Network Data;
      Hyunmo Kang, Catherine Plaisant, Bongshin Lee, Benjamin B. Bederson
    • ScentIndex and ScentHighlights: Productive Reading Techniques for Conceptually Reorganizing Subject Indexes and Highlighting Passages;
      Ed H. Chi, Lichan Hong, Julie Heiser, Stuart K. Card, Michelle Gumbrecht
    • Ewall: A Visual Analytics Environment for Collaborative Sense-Making;
      Paul E. Keel
    • A Visualization Testbed for Analyzing the Performance of Computational Linguistics Algorithms;
      Stephen G. Eick , Justin Mauger, Alan Ratner
    • An Automated Approach for the Optimization of Pixel Based Visualizations;
      Jörn Schneidewind, Mike Sips, Daniel A. Keim
    • Visual Analysis of Historic Hotel Visits;
      Chris Weaver, David Fyfe, Anthony Robinson, Deryck Holdsworth, Donna Peuquet, Alan M. MacEachren

    Posted in info vis, thesis ideas | Tagged: | Leave a Comment »

    List of Graph Visualization tools

    Posted by phdblogmeister on November 30, 2007

    List of Graph Visualization tools from http://www.visualcomplexity.com/vc/community/tools.cfm
    Easy
    Medium
    Advanced
    Other Resources
    - CAIDA Directory
    - SourceForge Directory
    - INSNA Directory
    - Google Directory
    - Wikipedia Directory
    - graphdrawing.org
    - List of Mind Mapping Software
    - List of Concept Mapping Software
    - Open Source Graphs in Java

    Posted in info vis, thesis ideas | Tagged: | Leave a Comment »

    visualcomplexity.com

    Posted by phdblogmeister on November 30, 2007

    A Working Brain Model Forces of Modernism Co-authorship Network - LRI Lab Typographic Links Resource System Reference Database Queens Library A social network visualization
    Mapping APRIL's Topological Distribution Maps series Visualizing the Aging Process Mobiglobe Flare Overlapper Google Mappish Mondrian
    Sharon Molloy's work EtherApe Mother Tongues of Computer Languages London Air Pollution in 3D CMM Skyrails Hyperonyme
    The Spread of Obesity in a Large Social Network Janice Caswell's Landscapes Road traffic between Swedish counties WikiMindMap Cinematic Particles orient - Migrating Architectures Map of Science
    Visual Medical Dictionary Facebook Friend Wheel Anymails The Product Space and the Wealth of Nations Hypergraph Generator Fidg't Visualizer Netflix Visualization

    from http://www.visualcomplexity.com/vc/
    methods: http://www.visualcomplexity.com/vc/method.cfm
    trends: http://www.visualcomplexity.com/vc/trend.cfm

    Posted in info vis, thesis ideas | Leave a Comment »

    Fascinated about visualization models and tools (Gallery 1)

    Posted by phdblogmeister on November 30, 2007

     http://prefuse.org/


    DocuBurst by Christopher Collins


    Uncertainty Lattices by Christopher Collins

     
    sense.us by Heer, Viégas, and Wattenberg

     
    StudiAnalyse by Christoph Gerstle and Florian Moritz

     
    Enron Explorer by Trampoline Systems

     
    Social Action by Adam Perer


    Nearword by Gregory Vaughan


    34all by Martin Dudek


    Zone Manager by Martin Dudek


    timeVis by Can Altineller


    Small-World Networks by Stephen Frowe Ingram


    NameVoyager by Martin Wattenberg, rebuilt by Jeffrey Heer


    ¢ongress by Jeffrey Heer


    zipdecode by Ben Fry, rebuilt by Jeffrey Heer


    TreeMap Demo by Jeffrey Heer


    RadialGraphView Demo by Jeffrey Heer


    TreeView Demo by Jeffrey Heer


    GraphView Demo by Jeffrey Heer


    FisheyeMenu Demo by Jeffrey Heer


    DataMountain Demo by Jeffrey Heer


    Vizster by Jeffrey Heer and danah boyd


    Flow Map Layout by Doantam

     PDF archive: vis.pdf

    Posted in info vis, thesis ideas | Tagged: | 1 Comment »

     
    Follow

    Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.